Game 1: Emmett Kelly (as Mystery Guest #1 and the panel is blindfolded) - ""Clown"" (salaried; he appears in his full ""sad clown"" costume; there is no post-game conversation since he is not allowed to speak in costume, as Arlene explains) Game 2: Mrs. Helen Moore - ""Mud Bath Attendant"" (salaried; she works at the Moore Mud Bath Hotel where she tends to the needs of female customers; from Waukesha, WI) Game 3: Dinah Shore (as Mystery Guest #2) Her segment is missing from the kinescope and is lost to history. See additional notes below. Game 4: Mrs. Selma Gitelman - ""Truant Officer"" (salaried; from Merrick, Long Island, NY) (thetvdb.com)