Game 1: Kitty Carlisle, Tom Poston, Orson Bean & Peggy Cass (as Mystery Guest Team from ""To Tell the Truth"") Tom Poston signed in for the gang by signing ""The To Tell The Truth Panel."" Game 2: Mrs. Sue Cox - ""Predicts Weekly Football Scores on Television"" (she works at WCCO-TV where her nickname is Bronco; she predicts both college scores and professional scores; her husband is football player Bobby Cox who was a quarterback for the University of Minnesota; from Minneapolis, MN) Game 3: George Segal (as Mystery Guest #2) Game 4: Walter Allen - ""Sells Light Bulbs"" (for the Royal Lamp Company, who are distributors for Westinghouse and Sylvania; from Manhattan, NY; he is also an acting student at the Lee Strasburg Actor's Studio; he is in a Christmas play for children at the Renata Theatre, """"Aladdin and His Wonderful Lamp."" (thetvdb.com)